When I was single, I would dread getting holiday cards. I would open the envelopes and be greeted by a baby picture, adorably coiffed little toddlers, or an entire family smiling back at me.
And even though I rolled my eyes, I wanted nothing more than to be able to send out one of those cards. A card with a happy, smiling family. The names and ages of all the sweet little children listed along the bottom. Perfect card, perfect family.
But, ha ha, the joke was on me. Even when I had a family, it was far from perfect.
And not until Joey was sick did we finally have one of "those" cards to send.
I remember the debacle of trying to take a photo for our holiday card the first year we had kids. We were living on Long Island and had no idea where to go for pictures, so we decided to take our own. Hubby and I were each holding a squirmy eleven month old baby. I put the camera on auto and kept running back and forth to reset it. The babies wouldn't smile, it was blurry for some reason, and we all had red-eye. I ended up just taking a cute picture of the babies in Christmas jammies, and Hubby thought of a funny holiday letter "top ten" a la David Letterman.
The next year, with three babies under the age of two, we made an appointment to have a professional photo taken. The photographer actually wanted 23 month old Joey to hold 4 month old Knox on his lap for the photo. Hubby and I stood just outside the frame with our arms outstretched ready to catch the baby should Joey drop him. Needless to say, we didn't get a picture that year. In fact, I don't think I even sent a card that year.
The next few years, as December approached, I would try to corral all the boys for a cute candid shot I could make into a card. I'd seen it for years on other people's cards. Remember the smiling, happy families? They'd be posed somewhere on vacation or at a pumpkin patch or in front of a Christmas display or cutely tangled in Christmas lights with Santa hats on.
All I ever got were blurry photos with someone either not looking at the camera, not smiling, or walking out of the frame.
When I started paying for professional photos of the boys, they turned out a little better, but all the photos were the same - all the little boys in a row sitting cross legged on the floor in front of a white background. Cute, but not very original.
Hubby and I never really cared to be in the pictures; therefore, we had no family pictures of us.
That is, until we found out Joey was dying. Then we scrambled to set up a photo session.
And ironically, I finally had my perfect candid shot of what appeared to be a perfect family:
This picture lies. It shows a darling, happy, vibrant family, Not a family who knows they will have to come to grips with losing one of their own. You wouldn't know that beautiful child in the middle was just given a death sentence.
The next year, after Joey's death, the last thing I wanted to do was send out Christmas cards. I had always signed each of our names on every card:
Love, Kathy, Hubby, Joey, Slim, Knox, and Lil' C.
How could I send out a picture and not sign all of our names? A picture that didn't include Joey because he was gone?
I didn't know if I was ever going to feel like sending out a Christmas card ever again.
But then, someone else showed up, and things changed. Suddenly, last year, we had a new baby. So I sent out a card with a picture we had taken ourselves.
Except for the mama's sad looking eyes in this picture, everyone looks happy. Although, I couldn't stop staring at the empty spot over my left shoulder thinking someone should be there. So I left all of our names off and signed it simply from The Frog Family.
This year, we decided it was time again for a nice family picture. I put off scheduling it, though. The certificate for the session was about to expire. We had to do it soon. I told the photographer about our situation. About missing someone from our family. She gave me an idea of how everyone could be in the picture together, even Joey and the new baby. Hubby wasn't so sure about it.
But then we saw the result:
For once, the picture doesn't lie. It shows a family. A happy family. But not a perfect family. A family who is missing someone. Someone who should be filling that space over my left shoulder.
Instead, he's filling that space in our hearts.
I signed all of our names: Kathy, Hubby, Slim, Knox, Lil' C, and Baby E. The photographer asked if I wanted to include Joey's name. I said we didn't need to.
The picture tells his story. The picture doesn't lie.



What a beautiful, beautiful story. You totally brought tears to my eyes. I love how you have embraced the beauty of authenticity rather than the quest for perfection, or the facade of perfection.
ReplyDeleteThe Christmas card can be a tricky thing. I actually decided not to send them out this year, but now I'm reconsidering. We'll see, I guess.
Thank you, Christie. You're right - the Christmas card can be tricky to get right.
DeleteDearest Kathy,
ReplyDeleteI found your blog this morning... and I have been reading so many of your posts with tears streaming down my cheeks. I am so, so sorry for your loss.
Thank you for visiting my blog. I lost our little boy when was 16 weeks pregnant. That was awful enough. I can't imagine how deathly painful it must be to lose a little someone who has been a part of your life for six years.
I am sending you a huge hug! Your family is just beautiful.
Sarah xoxo
Dear Kathy,
ReplyDeleteI have been avidly reading your blog this morning... with tears streaming down my face. I am so, so sorry for your loss.
We lost Henry when I was 16 weeks pregnant. That was awful enough. I can't imagine how painful it must have been to lose a sweet little six year old boy. Joey looked such a darling little chap.
My heart goes out to you. Thank you for writing about your experiences and feelings. I am sending you a huge hug!
Sarah xoxo
Thank you, Sarah. Sending a hug back for your loss as well.
DeleteA perfect picture of a real family. It is beautiful !
ReplyDeleteThanks Mary Ann. One is addressed and ready to go to you, my friend.
DeleteThat is so beautiful...I have tears in my eyes but what a great way to keep you darling boy present in your lives. Warm thoughts to you and yours.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Kimberly!
DeleteWhat a wonderful way to show the whole family. This is such a beautiful story. I cannot imagine what it is like to lose a child. *HUGS*
ReplyDeleteThank you. I really wanted a picture with Joey and our new little guy. I'm pleased with how it turned out.
DeleteWhat a beautiful way to honor your family and heart. Christmas cards do lie, don't they.Not yours, not this year. Thanks for sharing.
ReplyDeleteThank you. I'm hoping it will bring some comfort to our friends and family as well. It's just nice to see his smiling face. :)
DeleteOh Kathy, you brought tears to my eyes with this one! What a brilliant idea to include you all in the picture. Hugs to you!!!
ReplyDeleteThanks, Kelly!! I had wanted to do this for a while. I'm glad it turned out nicely.
DeleteLove the picture - hugs to you!
ReplyDeleteThanks Leslie!
DeleteThat is a beautiful family picture, Kathy! I love the framed picture of Joey. My 5-year-old nephew died in a car accident several years ago. In the most recent "grandkids" picture we had taken (there are 34 of them), we had his brother hold a baseball glove. Andy LOVED baseball and everyone in our family knows the significance of the glove.
ReplyDeleteThat was another thing the photographer suggested - to put in something that reminded us of Joey. That's something we'll definitely think about in coming years.
DeleteOh, that last picture. So beautiful. xoxo
ReplyDeleteI love it. :)
DeleteKathy, I am ugly crying over here. Just emotionally spent feeling with you and missing Joey with you because through your posts I feel like I knew him. I wish I could reach through and hug you. I wish I could take away your pain. I love, love, love the last picture. What a beautiful way to say that he is still here in spirit. I can see the sadness in your eyes in the second picture. Pictures do lie. A lot. Ours pretend every year that we are like everyone else. LIE.
ReplyDeleteThanks AnnMarie. I know you know the feeling of looking at an empty space and wishing someone was there, too. Hugs my friend.
Delete*tears* Such a touching post and beautiful pictures.
ReplyDeleteThank you, Jamie.
DeleteOh Kathy! I got chills and tears at the same time--what a perfect idea for a wonderful and honest pic. And you all look beautiful. I'm sure you will treasure this always...
ReplyDeleteDefinitely! I'm wondering how many more times we can do this before it's just strange. :/
DeleteJust trust your heart and no one will ever question it's strangeness. Praying for endurance & strength. - Sam
DeleteThank you for posting this. This year we wrote, "Love from the Sams Family. Matt, Susie, Oceana, Naomi, and Cora. Always remembering Joshua." ---- I need him to be acknowledged. And while I know that it hurts my husband to see his name, it hurt me more to not include him. "Do you have 3 children?" ---- Oh how my heart hurts, because no, I have 4. Love to you and your boys this Christmas.
ReplyDeleteSusie, I know exactly how you feel! I struggle with how to answer that question, too. Do I say 5 but...and then explain Joey's story or 5 and leave it at that? Somehow saying 4 doesn't seem right. Love to your family as well.
DeleteOh Kathy,
ReplyDeleteI don't know you, your family, or your story - I just stumbled on your blog and this post, and wow - what honest words from a wonderful strong mama. Much love to you.
<3
Thank you so much - for reading and commenting and sending the love. :)
Deletesuch a beautiful and touching way to include everybody in your family pic. This year I lost both of my dads, my natural and step dad, and it will be my first Christmas without both of them. Although I can only imagine the pain of losing a child, I try for myself to think of it as they are with me always, just not physically but always in my heart
ReplyDeleteKaren
Karen, I hope you find peace in good memories this holiday. Sending hugs and prayers.
DeleteIncredible post. I am moved beyond words. I just sit here at the computer crying, thinking how brave you are.
ReplyDeleteThanks Missy. Not sure if it's bravery, but definitely therapeutic!
DeleteYou're right, that photo turned out brilliantly. So many beautiful faces. One amazing family. I love it, and this post so much. We're taking the year off from Holiday cards...I wonder if anyone will even notice besides the Post Office ;) Sending great big hugs your way!
ReplyDeleteThanks, Jen. Feeling your great big hug and loving that you always make me laugh!
DeleteKathy, this is one of the most beautiful things I have ever seen. Forever family. Your Joey. Woven deep into the fabric of who you are. Always.
ReplyDeleteI am so sorry for your pain - a pain that I cannot imagine. I admire you, Kathy. Your honesty. Your bravery. And your ability to share with a heart wide-open.
I've been praying for the health of your family.
You've moved straight into my heart.
Thanks Shawnelle. I'm sure your prayers are powerful, so I will take them! I'm so glad to know you.
DeleteOh, Kathy. Honestly, I am crying right now. What a beautiful post and beautiful picture. You are such a lovely person and fabulous writer and I'm so happy to know you. Thanks for sharing this. Hugs and love!
ReplyDeleteOh, hon, you just make me feel so good. Thank you for your kind and beautiful words.
DeleteKathy, with tears streaming down my eyes I can barely see what I'm typing. This is just the most beautiful photograph. It is so touching an moving. It's beautiful. It's perfect.
ReplyDeleteI'm sure this time of year is very difficult for you. My thoughts and prayers are with you.
One thing is for sure, you make beautiful children.
Steph, you made me cry and laugh at the same time! Yes, it is always so hard to find the joy and happiness, but I have to remember it's about the boys. Thanks for your comment.
DeleteThat last photo...It's what pushed me over the edge--It could not be more beautiful. What a wonderful photographer. I'm so sorry for your family's loss. Thank you for sharing a piece of your heart.
ReplyDeleteSo beautiful! I am so glady you included Joey's picture. I wish we had done that for Jack. LOVE and HUGS to you today. xoxoxo
ReplyDeleteReally beautiful, as a mother who lost baby son,it really touched me. As time goes by its been 9 years, I find more women who share this bond weather it was a two year old, twenty year old or 40 yr old, you never stop being a Mom...As someone said "I don't know how you went through that" my reply is one of the pessimistic optimist or optimistic pessimist, "What choice did I have & things could be worse". Fools sometimes ask what could be worse, to which I answer,"You don't even want to get me started"....I had another child after Jacob...(my invisible pregnancy)....sometime say I have 4 kids,sometime 3, mostly I know my story its just hard for the other person to hear it so I spare them...but if we don't share our stories we don't ever find others with similar ones.....so we all just push on....Living, surviving,doing the best we can...thank you for the honest experience...Merry Christmas
ReplyDeleteOh don't I know this all too well! People have said I have such strength and grace, but what choice did I have? And I mostly always say that I have five children - sometimes I will tell Joey's story and sometimes I won't. Thanks for visiting. xoxo
DeleteI saw this in my newsfeed and had to read. What a beautifully honest and heartfelt post. Incredible. And now I'm off to read your blog!
ReplyDeleteWonderful tribute to your son! Thank you so much for writing this.
ReplyDeletePatti
Found your blog this morning on Huffington Post and will follow it from now on. Your heartfelt story touches me, as we "lost" a son to schizophrenia nine years ago, and he has not been part of the family since due to paranoia and delusions (he refuses to take medication). We also "lost" my husband to dementia. So, while he is here, he is not present. It took me years to do another family photo, and now it includes my remaining three adult children and me, but there is always a hole in my heart for who is missing. Your photographer's idea of a photo of Joey is perfect!
ReplyDeleteThank you for writing. Merry Christmas to you and your family.
Oh Kate, I'm so sorry for what you go through every day. There are all kinds of loss that we have to deal with when we have a family. None of it is easy, but we rely on each other to get us through. Sending you love and prayers from my mama heart. Thanks for visiting and following!! xo
DeleteI am so sorry for your loss. What a beautiful family. Thanks for sharing your story. It gives many of us strength.
ReplyDeleteMy heart broke for you as I read this. I know all about sad eyes even when smiling and pictures telling lies. I lost one of my twin girls last December two days after they were born. I cannot imagine the pain of losing a child you actually hsve years of memories with. I love this family photo idea and may do something similar! Many hugs!
ReplyDeleteThank you so much, Kat. Our situations are similar. We have lost the potential of our children - all that they were supposed to be. I think it hurts just as much at any age. I am keeping you in my mama heart now.
DeleteBeautiful story, thank you for sharing this.
ReplyDeleteThank you for sharing your story. My heart hurts for you after reading your post. You have a beautiful family.
ReplyDeleteThank you Beth.
DeleteBeautiful story, it brought tears to my eyes. I retweeted for my followers
ReplyDeleteThank you, Monica.
DeleteKathy,
ReplyDeleteYou are a beautiful spirit and a source of inspiration. You are the embodiment of courage. Two years ago I lost my best friend to a cancerous stage 4 brain tumor and the holidays, more than any other time of the year, are not the same. You ask yourself: "Should I celebrate in her honor or will others perceive my actions as disrespectful?" I commend you in doing what was right for YOU and your FAMILY. You and your family are in my prayers and thoughts. And know that your little angel is always by your left side.
I'm sure your friend is with you as well. It;s hard to feel joyous at a time everyone else is, but you're right - I think they would want us to.
DeleteWhat a beautiful story. I love this year's picture ... it shows that an awesome little boy is still a big part of your family. I am sorry that you had to experience that unimaginable loss. Belated Merry Christmas!
ReplyDeleteRead about this on AOL. Thank you for sharing your story.
ReplyDeleteI love your honesty. It's always inspiring to read a real story by a real person.
ReplyDeleteI am crying as I type. beautiful.
ReplyDeleteI have been meaning to comment on this post for ages, but the holidays got in the way, and then I thought it might be wrong to post and bring back bad memories for you. But then I remembered what a lot of people tell me after they lose someone - that the worst thing you can do is skirt around the issue and pretend the person never existed.
ReplyDeleteSo I'm commenting on this post almost a month after you posted it.
It touched me to my core. I loved everything about what you did, and I loved that he was included. It was just . . . perfect.
You are a wonderful and talented writer. Thank you so much for sharing your story.
Oh, and FYI - you have a new blog stalker. :)
xoxoxoxo
Thanks for coming back to comment. I'm glad that it touched you. Talking about Joey and having others talk to me about him helps me, so I never mind.
DeleteAnd as far as the blog stalking, I think it's mutual!!
Wow that brought me to tears. I'm so glad you did the picture with him in the frame. It was so wonderful and told the whole story.
ReplyDeleteAn amazing blog post!
what an incredible post. obviously it was quite hard to read through the tear streaming down my cheeks (my husband is now looking at me a bit strangely - I'll have to get him to read it too). Its a beautiful photo.
ReplyDeleteMy heart breaks for you that you lost Joey. I am so very sorry. Thank you for touching post.
ReplyDeleteWow. What a powerful piece. And I am now addicted to your blog. So, get ready for a whole lot of smart ass....
ReplyDeleteTracy @ Momaical
So sorry you had to go through this. Tears well up in my eyes for you and your family. I adore the last photo, the photo of a family that will never forget a special little member.
ReplyDeleteoh Kathy, I have no words only hugs. Popping by to introduce myself from KBN and well, now I feel as if I know you. At least a little bit, I'll be getting to know you much more and just wanted to say from one mother to another I am here for you. Your family is wonderful and I can already tell I will be addicted to reading all about them. Thank you for having the courage to share your story. ~ Stacy
ReplyDeleteStacy, thank you for coming by and commenting. I think as moms we have to share our stories, no matter how hard or difficult.
DeleteMay be the most precious post I have ever read.
ReplyDelete